If you loved
Small Town Murder
James Pietragallo, Jimmie Whisman · Podcast · 2026
If Small Town Murder hooked you, it is because you appreciate how dark, provincial secrets collide with sharp, irreverent social commentary.
Books on the same thread
Child of God
Lolita Files · Book · 2001
Like Small Town Murder, this narrative mines the tragic irony found in small-town family legacies, forcing you to confront how community history can hide the darkest of secrets.
The Heaven & Earth Grocery Store
James McBride · Book · 2023
You will appreciate how this story unearths deep-seated community prejudices through a central mystery, mirroring the sociological observations that define the investigative process in Small Town Murder.
Homicide
David Simon · Book · 2007
If the forensic breakdown of local crime is your favorite part of Small Town Murder, you will value this unflinching look at the systemic realities of homicide investigation.
All My Friends Are Dead
Avery Monsen, Jory John · Book · 2013
This book captures the same gallows humor that makes Small Town Murder bearable, using a dark, ironic lens to process the inevitability of human misery and mortality.
Films on the same thread
The Thursday Murder Club
Chris Columbus · Film · 2025
The blend of comedy and crime in this story offers a lighter, yet equally engaging, take on the amateur detective work that makes Small Town Murder so compelling.
Eddington
Film · 2025
This film captures the explosive nature of small-town politics found in Small Town Murder, illustrating how power struggles can turn neighbors into enemies within a confined, provincial setting.
Mississippi Burning
Alan Parker · Film · 1988
You will recognize the conspiracy of silence prevalent in Small Town Murder as this film exposes the racial injustice and secrets buried deep within a small Southern community.
Tragedy Girls
Film · 2017
This satire of true crime culture echoes the cynical, comedic spirit of Small Town Murder, lampooning the obsession with notoriety that often follows tragic events in small towns.
Series on the same thread
Only Murders in the Building
Steve Martin · Series · 2021
Just as the hosts of Small Town Murder analyze cases from a distance, this show highlights the addictive nature of true crime obsession while keeping the atmosphere light.
American Vandal
Dan Perrault · Series · 2017
This mockumentary mirrors the investigative format of Small Town Murder, providing a satirical look at a local mystery while maintaining a sharp, critical eye on its subjects.
Penn & Teller: Bull!
Eric Small · Series · 2003
If you enjoy the skeptical, no-nonsense debunking found in Small Town Murder, you will appreciate how this series uses critical thinking to dismantle widely held cultural beliefs.
Honeymoon Se Hatya
Mrunalini Havaldar · Series · 2026
This series focuses on the fatal breakdown of domestic life, offering the same deep dive into the underlying motives and tragic secrets that drive the narratives in Small Town Murder.
Keep exploring
Common questions
What is the premise of Small Town Murder?
Small Town Murder features two comedians who examine a specific small town and the murder that occurred there. The podcast combines in-depth research regarding the tragedy with the hosts' comedic perspective on the location and the events that took place.
How often are new episodes of Small Town Murder released?
New episodes of Small Town Murder are released every Thursday. The show is hosted by James Pietragallo and Jimmie Whisman, who provide their comedic spin on cases while detailing the history and atmosphere of the small towns they research for each episode.
Who are the hosts of Small Town Murder?
The hosts of Small Town Murder are James Pietragallo and Jimmie Whisman. Together, they research specific crimes and the small towns where they occurred, presenting the information through a mix of serious investigative detail and their own comedic commentary.
Is Small Town Murder a comedy podcast?
Small Town Murder is a podcast that blends comedy with true crime. While the hosts provide a comedic spin on the subject matter, the show is also defined by the in-depth research conducted into the horrible tragedies and the history of the small towns featured in each episode.