What to read, watch, and listen to if you lovedOld Soul
Susan Barker · Book · 2026
If you loved Old Soul, start with Hokum (Damian McCarthy, 2026) — a film on the same thread. Below: 4 films, 4 series and 2 podcasts, each matched to Old Soul across media.
What hooked you in Old Soul was the way the weight of past trauma manifests as an inescapable, haunting, and interconnected mystery.
Films on the same thread
Hokum
Damian McCarthy · Film · 2026
Shares a thread with Old Soul: Psychological Horror.
Like the protagonist of Old Soul, you will appreciate how this film uses the burden of grief and haunted locations to blur the lines between reality and psychological collapse.
Soulm8te
Kate Dolan · Film · 2026
Explores: artificial consciousness, grief, technological hubris.
If Old Soul hit, Soulm8te shares the thread.
Remarkably Bright Creatures
Olivia Newman · Film · 2026
Explores: Grief and healing, Intergenerational friendship, Hidden secrets.
If Old Soul hit, Remarkably Bright Creatures shares the thread.
undertone
Ian Tuason · Film · 2026
Shares 2 threads with Old Soul: obsession, Supernatural mystery.
If the obsessive search for answers in Old Soul kept you turning pages, you will be drawn to this story of a podcaster unraveling a terrifying, interconnected supernatural mystery.
Series on the same thread
IT: Welcome to Derry
Andy Muschietti · Series · 2025
Shares a thread with Old Soul: Supernatural Mystery.
If Old Soul hit, IT: Welcome to Derry shares the thread.
The Outsider
Richard Price · Series · 2020
Explores: Good vs Evil, Skepticism vs Belief, Grief and Loss.
Much like Old Soul, this series masterfully weaves grief and loss into a dark mystery, forcing characters to confront an insidious supernatural force that defies their rational understanding.
The Beast in Me
Gabe Rotter · Series · 2025
Shares 2 threads with Old Soul: Obsession, Mystery Thriller.
The intense focus on obsession and hidden identity in Old Soul finds a perfect match here as a famous author becomes trapped in a dangerous game with a mysterious neighbor.
Every Year After
Series · 2026
Explores: soulmates, nostalgia, long-term relationship.
If Old Soul hit, Every Year After shares the thread.
Podcasts on the same thread
Monsters Among Us
Derek Hayes | Audioboom Studios · Podcast · 2026
Shares a thread with Old Soul: Supernatural Mystery.
The atmospheric horror and emphasis on first-hand testimony in this podcast mirror the chilling, experiential dread that defines the search for truth within the pages of Old Soul.
Lore
Aaron Mahnke · Podcast · 2026
Explores: Dark History, Supernatural, Mysterious Events.
If you were captivated by the historical traces and tragic narratives in Old Soul, this exploration of dark folklore and mysterious events will provide the same unsettling sense of history.
Keep exploring
Common questions
Is Old Soul a standalone novel?
Yes, Old Soul by Susan Barker is a standalone literary horror novel published in 2026. The story follows two strangers, Jake and Mariko, as they investigate a mysterious woman linked to their pasts, and there are no sequels or series installments associated with this specific title.
What is the central mystery in Old Soul?
The central mystery in Old Soul revolves around a beguiling woman who has vanished. Jake and Mariko discover they have both suffered the brutal loss of loved ones who crossed paths with this same individual, leading them to follow the traces she left behind in Osaka.
Who are the main characters in Old Soul?
The main characters in Old Soul are Jake and Mariko. These two strangers meet in Osaka after missing a flight and realize they are connected by the shared, tragic loss of loved ones who were involved with the same mysterious woman.
What kind of book is Old Soul?
Old Soul is a literary horror novel written by Susan Barker. It is described as a searingly provocative story that examines one woman’s determination to stay alive at any cost, blending elements reminiscent of The Historian and Under the Skin within its narrative.