What to read, watch, and listen to if you lovedKeeping the Faith
Edward Norton · Film · 2000
If you loved Keeping the Faith, start with Nobody Wants This (Erin Foster, 2024) — a series on the same thread. Below: 4 books, 4 series and 2 podcasts, each matched to Keeping the Faith across media.
If Keeping the Faith charmed you, these stories explore the delicate intersection of personal identity, deep friendship, and the complexities of modern belief.
Books on the same thread
Have a Little Faith: A True Story
Mitch Albom · Book · 2009
Explores: Faith, Interfaith Dialogue, Poverty.
Like Keeping the Faith, this memoir examines the bridge between different religious traditions and the profound, grounding power of human connection within the context of spiritual service.
A Prayer for Owen Meany
John Irving · Book · 1989
Explores: Faith and Doubt, Fate vs. Free Will, Friendship.
You will recognize the central focus on lifelong friendship and the search for meaning that defined Keeping the Faith as these characters navigate fate, doubt, and spiritual destiny.
The Keep
F. Paul Wilson · Book · 2000
Explores: Ancient Evil, Nazi Occultism, Good vs Evil.
While darker in tone than Keeping the Faith, this story centers on a Jewish protagonist whose cultural identity informs his perspective when facing an unexpected and supernatural threat.
Atonement
Ian McEwan · Book · 2007
Shares a thread with Keeping the Faith: Forbidden Love.
Much like the emotional stakes in Keeping the Faith, this narrative explores how childhood bonds and past choices resonate through time, shaping the paths of adults seeking personal forgiveness.
Series on the same thread
Father Ted
Arthur Mathews · Series · 1995
Shares a thread with Keeping the Faith: Clergy.
If you enjoyed the lighthearted look at the lives of clergy in Keeping the Faith, you will appreciate this satirical take on the daily struggles of parish priests.
Unorthodox
Anna Winger · Series · 2020
Explores: arranged marriage, religious conflict, cultural identity.
This drama mirrors the tension found in Keeping the Faith regarding religious identity, focusing on a woman who must reconcile her traditional upbringing with her desire for personal independence.
Friends
Marta Kauffman · Series · 1994
Explores: Friendship, Relationships, Coming of Age.
The camaraderie of city life in Keeping the Faith is echoed here, as this group of friends navigates the pressures of adulthood and the comfort found in their tight-knit bond.
Nobody Wants This
Erin Foster · Series · 2024
Shares 2 threads with Keeping the Faith: Interfaith Romance, Romantic Comedy.
This series is the perfect follow-up to Keeping the Faith, directly exploring the comedic and emotional hurdles of an interfaith romance complicated by family expectations and modern life.
Podcasts on the same thread
THE ADAM BUXTON PODCAST
ADAM BUXTON · Podcast
Explores: east anglia, family life, dog ownership.
The blend of humor and serious reflection found in Keeping the Faith carries over to these conversations, which balance lighthearted banter with deeper, more meaningful human connection.
Conan O’Brien Needs A Friend
Team Coco & Earwolf · Podcast · 2026
Explores: parasocial relationships, professional intimacy, self-deprecating humor.
Fans of the charismatic, conversational chemistry in Keeping the Faith will enjoy this exploration of professional intimacy and the genuine search for friendship amidst a high-pressure career.
Keep exploring
Common questions
Is Keeping the Faith a movie about a love triangle?
Yes, Keeping the Faith follows the complicated relationship between childhood friends Rabbi Jacob Schram, Father Brian Finn, and Anna Reilly. After Anna returns to New York, she reenters the lives of both men, creating a complex romantic dynamic between the three protagonists.
What is the primary setting of Keeping the Faith?
Keeping the Faith is set in New York City, specifically on the Upper West Side. The story focuses on the lives and work of the two male leads as they navigate their professional roles and their rekindled connection with Anna Reilly.
Who directed Keeping the Faith?
Keeping the Faith was directed by Edward Norton, who also stars in the film. The story centers on the lives of two best friends, a rabbi and a priest, whose long-standing friendship is tested when a childhood friend returns to their lives.
Is Keeping the Faith based on a story about childhood friends?
Yes, Keeping the Faith depicts the story of Rabbi Jacob Schram and Father Brian Finn, who have been best friends since they were children. Their bond is challenged when their childhood friend, Anna Reilly, returns to the city as an adult.