What to read, watch, and listen to if you lovedInto The Dark
Podcast
If you loved Into The Dark, start with In the Dark (Corinne Kingsbury, 2019) — a series on the same thread. Below: 4 books, 3 films and 4 series, each matched to Into The Dark across media.
You clearly crave that unsettling intersection where rigorous investigative obsession collides with the inexplicable, darker corners of the human experience.
Books on the same thread
I'll Be Gone in the Dark
Michelle McNamara · Book · 2019
Shares a thread with Into The Dark: Criminal Psychology.
Much like Into The Dark, this book captures the consuming nature of cold case obsession, mirroring the drive to uncover truth when the trail has long gone cold.
Chaos
Tom O'Neill with Dan Piepenbring · Book
Explores: Institutional corruption, Cult psychology, Hidden history.
If the conspiracy-laden episodes of Into The Dark resonate with you, this deep dive into institutional corruption and hidden history will satisfy your hunger for unsettling, systemic truths.
All Good People Here
Ashley Flowers · Book · 2022
Explores: Small Town Secrets, Unsolved Murder, True Crime Obsession.
This novel echoes the investigative intensity of Into The Dark, following a journalist whose personal connection to an unsolved murder pulls her into a web of dark secrets.
Unmasked
Paul Holes · Book
Shares a thread with Into The Dark: Criminal psychology.
This memoir provides the same forensic grit found in Into The Dark, offering a firsthand look at the psychological toll of investigating cases that defy easy explanation.
Films on the same thread
undertone
Ian Tuason · Film · 2026
Shares a thread with Into The Dark: paranormal investigation.
Like Into The Dark, this film centers on the unsettling fallout of paranormal investigation, where the line between the researcher and the haunted becomes dangerously blurred.
Dark Places
Gilles Paquet-Brenner · Film · 2015
Explores: False Memory Syndrome, Trauma, Small Town Secrets.
This film digs into the same psychological trauma and small-town darkness that Payton Moreland explores weekly on Into The Dark, focusing on the weight of buried memories.
In the Mouth of Madness
John Carpenter · Film · 1995
Explores: Reality Bending, The Power of Narrative, Sanity vs. Madness.
This narrative mirrors the mysterious, reality-bending tone of Into The Dark, as an investigator faces the terrifying realization that his case involves forces beyond rational understanding.
Series on the same thread
I'll Be Gone in the Dark
Liz Garbus · Series · 2020
Explores: Citizen Detective, Obsessive Investigation, Cold Case.
This documentary perfectly reflects the investigative spirit of Into The Dark, documenting an obsessive quest for justice that mirrors the show's own focus on haunting, unsolved cases.
Cold Case Files
Series · 1999
Explores: Unsolved Mysteries, Criminal Investigation, Forensic Science.
If you enjoy the procedural aspect of Into The Dark, these cases will satisfy your interest in the persistent, evolving work required to solve long-standing mysteries.
In the Dark
Corinne Kingsbury · Series · 2019
Explores: Blind protagonist, Disability representation, Murder investigation.
This series captures the investigative focus of Into The Dark, though it trades the show's dark, atmospheric tone for a sharp, irreverent take on solving a murder.
The Outsider
Richard Price · Series · 2020
Explores: Good vs Evil, Skepticism vs Belief, Grief and Loss.
This show bridges the gap between grounded crime and the supernatural, mirroring the way Into The Dark weaves paranormal curiosity into its core investigations of human cruelty.
Keep exploring
Common questions
When are new episodes of Into The Dark released?
New episodes of Into The Dark are released every Wednesday. Each weekly installment features host Payton Moreland as she examines a different true crime case, while also exploring topics related to mysteries, hauntings, and conspiracy theories.
What is the primary focus of the Into The Dark podcast?
Into The Dark is a true crime podcast that incorporates elements of horror and mystery. Host Payton Moreland breaks down the facts of a new case each week and explores the psychological motivations behind criminal behavior.
Does Into The Dark cover topics other than true crime?
Yes, Into The Dark periodically discusses subjects beyond standard true crime cases. Payton Moreland includes episodes that delve into conspiracy theories, hauntings, and other spooky phenomena to complement the show's core focus on mystery and crime.
Is Into The Dark a serialized podcast?
No, Into The Dark is not a serialized podcast. Each weekly episode features Payton Moreland as she delves into a different, self-contained case, allowing listeners to jump into the show at any time without needing to follow a continuous narrative.