If you loved
Holly
Stephen King · Book · 2023
If you loved Holly, you will be drawn to these stories that navigate the thin, harrowing line between obsessive investigation and personal psychological unraveling.
Films on the same thread
A Haunting in Venice
Kenneth Branagh · Film · 2023
Explores: Skepticism vs. Belief, Grief and Loss, Guilt and Redemption.
Like Holly, this story features a brilliant investigator forced out of isolation to confront a dark mystery where skepticism clashes with the unsettling reality of the supernatural.
Missing
Film · 2023
Explores: Digital investigation, Family secrets, Parent-child relationships.
Much like the desperate search in Holly, this narrative captures the relentless, technology-driven pursuit of a missing loved one when traditional authorities are hindered by complications.
The Black Phone
Scott Derrickson · Film · 2022
Shares a thread with Holly: Trauma.
This film mirrors the grim reality of serial kidnappings found in Holly, focusing on the harrowing resilience required to survive a predator while trapped in isolation.
To Catch a Killer
Damián Szifron · Film · 2023
Shares 2 threads with Holly: Psychological Thriller, Serial Killer Thriller.
Fans of the detective work in Holly will appreciate this focus on a troubled investigator tasked with profiling a dangerous mass murderer in a high-stakes urban environment.
Series on the same thread
IT: Welcome to Derry
Andy Muschietti · Series · 2025
Explores: Childhood Trauma, Ancient Evil, Group of Friends.
This story echoes the small-town dread and hidden secrets present in Holly, centering on a group confronting an ancient, encroaching evil that threatens their community.
Evil
Michelle King · Series · 2019
Explores: Skepticism vs. Faith, Good vs. Evil, The Nature of Belief.
Those who enjoyed the analytical mind of Holly will value this procedural approach to the unexplained, where psychological expertise is used to evaluate potential demonic threats.
Only Murders in the Building
Steve Martin · Series · 2021
Explores: True Crime Obsession, New York City, Intergenerational Friendship.
This series captures the true crime obsession that drives the characters in Holly, blending amateur sleuthing with the personal stakes of being deeply involved in a mystery.
The Following
Kevin Williamson · Series · 2013
Shares 2 threads with Holly: Obsession, Psychological Thriller.
The cat-and-mouse dynamic between investigator and killer in Holly is perfectly reflected here, as a former agent is drawn back into a dangerous, obsessive hunt.
Podcasts on the same thread
Crime Junkie
Audiochuck · Podcast · 2026
Shares a thread with Holly: obsession.
If the investigative intensity of Holly kept you gripped, this podcast feeds that same need to scour every detail and uncover the truth behind infamous criminal cases.
My Favorite Murder with Karen Kilgariff and Georgia Hardstark
Exactly Right and iHeartPodcasts · Podcast · 2026
Explores: mental health awareness, female friendship, coping mechanisms.
This show mirrors the community-driven interest in true crime that characterizes the world of Holly, offering a conversational look at the darker side of human behavior.
Keep exploring
Common questions
Is Holly Gibney working at Finders Keepers during the events of Holly?
Yes, Holly is working at the Finders Keepers detective agency when she accepts the case from Penny Dahl. Although she is meant to be on leave and her partner Pete is ill with Covid, she chooses to take on the investigation into the disappearance of Bonnie Dahl.
Why does Holly decide to take the case in the book Holly?
Holly initially feels reluctant to accept the case because her mother has recently passed away and her partner Pete is sick. However, she ultimately decides to help Penny Dahl because there is something in the mother's desperate voice that makes it impossible for her to turn the case down.
Does Holly have any personal distractions at the start of Holly?
Yes, Holly faces several personal challenges at the beginning of the book. She is dealing with the recent death of her complicated mother, her partner Pete is suffering from Covid, and she is technically supposed to be on leave from her work at the Finders Keepers detective agency.
Where does the disappearance in Holly take place?
The disappearance of Bonnie Dahl, which serves as the primary mystery in Holly, occurs just blocks away from where her mother, Penny Dahl, resides. This proximity is a key detail that draws Holly into the investigation despite her initial hesitation to take on new work.