What to read, watch, and listen to if you lovedHolly
Stephen King · Book · 2023
If you loved Holly, start with A Haunting in Venice (Kenneth Branagh, 2023) — a film on the same thread. Below: 4 films, 4 series and 2 podcasts, each matched to Holly across media.
What hooked you in Holly was the way investigative procedure collides with the unsettling reality of ordinary people harboring monstrous secrets.
Films on the same thread
A Haunting in Venice
Kenneth Branagh · Film · 2023
Explores: Skepticism vs. Belief, Grief and Loss, Guilt and Redemption.
Like Holly, this mystery centers on a sharp-minded detective navigating a claustrophobic environment to uncover the dark, hidden motives of those who seem perfectly respectable on the surface.
Hokum
Damian McCarthy · Film · 2026
Explores: Haunted locations, Trauma-induced hallucinations, Unreliable narrator.
You will recognize the same oppressive atmosphere found in Holly as the protagonist is forced to peel back layers of trauma to confront a chilling, localized threat.
The Thursday Murder Club
Chris Columbus · Film · 2025
Explores: Retirement Community, Friendship, Justice.
This story mirrors the procedural focus of Holly, shifting the perspective to a group of seniors who rely on their unique life experiences to outsmart dangerous criminals.
Sleeping Dogs
Adam Cooper · Film · 2024
Explores: Memory Loss, Redemption, Moral Ambiguity.
Just as Holly tracks a cold case with obsessive detail, this narrative follows a detective struggling with his own history while piecing together a long-buried, brutal murder.
Series on the same thread
Evil
Michelle King · Series · 2019
Explores: Skepticism vs. Faith, Good vs. Evil, The Nature of Belief.
Fans of Holly will appreciate this methodical look at how a forensic expert must reconcile scientific skepticism with the terrifying possibility of inexplicable, malevolent forces at play.
The Outsider
Richard Price · Series · 2020
Explores: Good vs Evil, Skepticism vs Belief, Grief and Loss.
This series captures the exact investigative intensity of Holly, pitting a grounded, skeptical investigator against a dark, encroaching evil hidden within the quiet heart of a community.
IT: Welcome to Derry
Andy Muschietti · Series · 2025
Explores: Childhood Trauma, Ancient Evil, Group of Friends.
If you enjoyed the small-town dread in Holly, you will be drawn to this exploration of how ancient, buried evil manifests within the lives of seemingly ordinary people.
Only Murders in the Building
Steve Martin · Series · 2021
Explores: True Crime Obsession, New York City, Intergenerational Friendship.
This show shares the true-crime obsession that drives Holly, focusing on the thrill of the hunt and the way amateur sleuths become consumed by the mysteries they investigate.
Podcasts on the same thread
Small Town Murder
James Pietragallo, Jimmie Whisman · Podcast · 2026
Explores: provincial life, tragic irony, forensic breakdown.
Much like the investigative process in Holly, this podcast dissects the sociological underpinnings of small-town tragedies, revealing how quickly a normal life can unravel into a nightmare.
Something About Cari
Podcast
Explores: Disappearance, Stalking, Arson.
This narrative mirrors the unsettling disappearance case in Holly, focusing on the terrifying, slow-motion descent into a world of stalking and deception that hides behind a domestic facade.
Keep exploring
Common questions
Is Holly a standalone story?
Holly is a self-contained narrative featuring the private detective Holly Gibney. While she appears in other works, this specific book focuses on her solitary investigation into the disappearance of Bonnie Dahl and the suspicious activities of a married pair of octogenarian academics.
What is the primary mystery in Holly?
The primary mystery in Holly involves the private detective Holly Gibney working to uncover the truth behind the disappearance of Bonnie Dahl. She specifically investigates whether a married pair of octogenarian academics are responsible for the crime during her professional inquiry.
Does Holly involve a private investigator?
Yes, the protagonist of Holly is the private detective Holly Gibney. The plot follows her professional efforts as she investigates a missing person case, focusing specifically on the potential involvement of an elderly academic couple in the disappearance of Bonnie Dahl.
Who is the main character in Holly?
The main character in Holly is the private detective Holly Gibney. The book follows her investigation into the disappearance of Bonnie Dahl, as she attempts to determine if a married pair of octogenarian academics played a role in the event.