What to read, watch, and listen to if you lovedGirl, Forgotten
Karin Slaughter · Book
If you loved Girl, Forgotten, start with Karen Pirie (Emer Kenny, 2022) — a series on the same thread. Below: 4 films, 4 series and 2 podcasts, each matched to Girl, Forgotten across media.
If you loved Girl, Forgotten, you will be drawn to these stories where buried secrets from the past resurface to shatter present-day lives.
Films on the same thread
The Housemaid
Paul Feig · Film · 2025
Explores: Class Conflict, Gaslighting, Identity Theft.
Much like the tension found in Girl, Forgotten, this story centers on a woman attempting to outrun her past, only to find herself trapped in a web of dangerous secrets.
The Quiet Girl
Colm Bairéad · Film · 2022
Explores: neglect, found family, rural life.
Fans of the atmosphere in Girl, Forgotten will appreciate how this narrative reveals that even the quietest, most idyllic rural settings can harbor long-hidden truths that demand to be uncovered.
Remarkably Bright Creatures
Olivia Newman · Film · 2026
Explores: Grief and healing, Intergenerational friendship, Hidden secrets.
This story mirrors the emotional weight of Girl, Forgotten by showing how a single hidden discovery can fundamentally alter a life and bridge the gap between generations.
Sleeping Dogs
Adam Cooper · Film · 2024
Explores: Memory Loss, Redemption, Moral Ambiguity.
If you enjoyed the procedural intensity of Girl, Forgotten, you will be gripped by this investigation where a fractured memory makes uncovering the truth of a cold case perilous.
Series on the same thread
Sharp Objects
Marti Noxon · Series · 2018
Explores: Trauma, Small Town Secrets, Dysfunctional Family.
This series captures the same dark, small-town feeling as Girl, Forgotten, as the protagonist is forced to return home to confront the haunting trauma of her own history.
Unforgotten
Chris Lang · Series · 2015
Explores: Moral Ambiguity, Redemption, Secrets and Lies.
Readers of Girl, Forgotten will recognize the focus on justice-seeking detectives who meticulously peel back layers of history to resolve cold cases that have long been forgotten.
Karen Pirie
Emer Kenny · Series · 2022
Explores: Unsolved Mysteries, Small Town Secrets, Justice.
Just as in Girl, Forgotten, this mystery highlights the persistence required to solve a decades-old crime when a fresh look at the evidence reveals new, uncomfortable truths.
All Her Fault
Megan Gallagher · Series · 2025
Explores: Missing Child, Parental Fears, Suburban Secrets.
This story shares the unsettling suburban tension of Girl, Forgotten, where a simple, everyday situation spirals into a nightmare as hidden identities and past secrets are forced to light.
Podcasts on the same thread
CounterClock
Audiochuck · Podcast · 2025
Explores: unsolved homicide, seeking justice, historical mystery.
If you were captivated by the cold case investigation in Girl, Forgotten, you will appreciate this investigative approach that turns back time to finally secure justice for a victim.
Small Town Forgotten
Podcast
Explores: Small Town Murder, Personal Connection to Case, Local History.
This podcast echoes the local focus of Girl, Forgotten by examining how personal connections to a small town can complicate the pursuit of truth in a cold case.
Keep exploring
Common questions
Is Girl, Forgotten a standalone story?
Girl, Forgotten follows U.S. Marshal Andrea Oliver as she investigates a cold case from 1982 while protecting a judge in Longbill Beach. It functions as a specific narrative centered on this investigation, focusing on the events surrounding the cold case within the setting of the book.
What is the primary setting of Girl, Forgotten?
The primary setting for the events in Girl, Forgotten is Longbill Beach. This is where U.S. Marshal Andrea Oliver is stationed to provide protection for a judge before she ultimately becomes involved in uncovering the details of a cold case that dates back to 1982.
What is the central mystery in Girl, Forgotten?
The central mystery in Girl, Forgotten involves a cold case from 1982 that U.S. Marshal Andrea Oliver begins to investigate. While her original assignment in Longbill Beach is to protect a judge, the narrative shifts to uncovering the truth behind this long-unsolved case.
Who is the main character in Girl, Forgotten?
The main character in Girl, Forgotten is U.S. Marshal Andrea Oliver. She travels to Longbill Beach to fulfill a protective detail for a judge, which leads her to investigate a cold case originating from 1982, serving as the focal point of the story.