What to read, watch, and listen to if you lovedEvery Secret Thing
Amy J. Berg · Film · 2014
If you loved Every Secret Thing, start with We Are All Guilty Here (Karin Slaughter) — a book on the same thread. Below: 4 books, 4 series and 2 podcasts, each matched to Every Secret Thing across media.
If you were captivated by Every Secret Thing, you will be drawn to these stories exploring how small-town secrets shatter community trust.
Books on the same thread
We Are All Guilty Here
Karin Slaughter · Book
Explores: Secrets and lies, Missing persons, Community corruption.
Like Every Secret Thing, this narrative centers on the intersection of police procedure and the crushing weight of secrets held within a close-knit, suspicious community.
All the Missing Girls
Megan Miranda · Book · 2017
Shares a thread with Every Secret Thing: Psychological Thriller.
This story mirrors the haunting atmosphere of Every Secret Thing by forcing a protagonist to confront the suffocating influence of past trauma and lingering neighborhood mysteries.
Where are the Children?
Mary Higgins Clark · Book · 1992
Shares 2 threads with Every Secret Thing: Child abduction, False accusation.
If the themes of wrongful accusation and parental grief in Every Secret Thing resonated with you, this classic thriller offers a similarly intense exploration of public scrutiny.
Catching Temptation
Sarah Ann Erber · Book · 2014
Explores: Guilt, Resurrection, Monsters.
This pick echoes the small-town paranoia found in Every Secret Thing, shifting the focus to how a history of disappearances shapes the collective guilt of local residents.
Series on the same thread
Mare of Easttown
Brad Ingelsby · Series · 2021
Shares 3 threads with Every Secret Thing: Redemption, Detective Fiction, Psychological Thriller.
Fans of Every Secret Thing will appreciate this look at a community struggling with redemption and trauma as a detective navigates the wreckage of a local crime.
All Her Fault
Megan Gallagher · Series · 2025
Shares a thread with Every Secret Thing: Psychological Thriller.
This series captures the suburban dread present in Every Secret Thing, focusing on the immediate panic and confusion that erupts when a child goes missing unexpectedly.
Stranger Things
Ross Duffer · Series · 2016
Explores: Government Experiments, Telekinesis, Monsters.
This narrative utilizes the same small-town mystery framework as Every Secret Thing to explore how a missing child forces a community to confront its buried secrets.
The Missing
Harry Williams · Series · 2014
Shares a thread with Every Secret Thing: Psychological Thriller.
This series offers a profound look at the emotional fallout of child abduction, mirroring the deep community impact and lingering obsession depicted in Every Secret Thing.
Podcasts on the same thread
Every Town
Podcast
Explores: Small Town Crime, Unsolved Mysteries, Local Legends.
This podcast explores the same dark undercurrents of local life that define Every Secret Thing, focusing on the unsettling reality behind seemingly quiet and ordinary neighborhoods.
The Truth About Amy
LiSTNR · Podcast
Explores: Domestic Violence, Wrongful Death, Police Investigation.
Much like the investigative intensity of Every Secret Thing, this series examines the tragic disappearance of a mother and the complex police work following the event.
Keep exploring
Common questions
Is Every Secret Thing based on a true story?
Every Secret Thing is a 2014 film directed by Amy J. Berg. The plot follows two young girls who serve seven years for a baby's disappearance in a Baltimore suburb and are later investigated when another child goes missing. It is a fictional narrative, not a documentary.
What is the central mystery in Every Secret Thing?
The mystery in Every Secret Thing revolves around the disappearance of a baby from a Baltimore suburb. After two girls serve seven years for the crime, they are released into a community that has not forgiven them. The investigation intensifies when a second child goes missing in the same town.
How long is the runtime of Every Secret Thing?
Every Secret Thing is a 2014 film directed by Amy J. Berg. While the provided metadata does not specify the exact runtime in minutes, it details a story about two detectives investigating a series of child disappearances in a community where everyone seems to have a secret.
Where does the story of Every Secret Thing take place?
Every Secret Thing is set in a Baltimore suburb. This location serves as the backdrop for the investigation into the disappearance of a baby and the subsequent events that occur after the two responsible girls are released back into the community seven years later.