What to read, watch, and listen to if you lovedAmerican Predator
Maureen Callahan (Journalist) · Book · 2019
If you loved American Predator, start with Park Predators — a podcast on the same thread. Below: 4 films, 4 series and 2 podcasts, each matched to American Predator across media.
What hooked you in American Predator was the unsettling intersection of meticulous investigative work and the terrifying unpredictability of human monsters.
Films on the same thread
Predator: Killer of Killers
Dan Trachtenberg · Film · 2025
Explores: Survival, Hunter vs. Prey, Evolution.
If American Predator hit, Predator: Killer of Killers shares the thread.
Killers of the Flower Moon
Film · 2023
Shares a thread with American Predator: True Crime.
Much like American Predator, this film highlights the friction between systemic failure and the slow, methodical FBI investigation required to expose a hidden, calculated evil in our history.
Longlegs
Osgood Perkins · Film · 2024
Explores: FBI Agent, Personal Connection to Killer, Race Against Time.
You will appreciate the cold, clinical pursuit of a serial killer found in American Predator mirrored here through the lens of occult-tinged psychological horror and intense procedural focus.
The Frozen Ground
Scott Walker · Film · 2013
Shares a thread with American Predator: True Crime.
This film captures the same harrowing predator-prey dynamic present in American Predator, focusing on the difficult, real-world efforts of law enforcement to track a ghost-like killer in Alaska.
Series on the same thread
MINDHUNTER
Joe Penhall · Series · 2017
Shares 3 threads with American Predator: Serial Killers, FBI Investigation, True Crime.
Fans of the FBI-centric narrative in American Predator will value this deep dive into the development of criminal profiling techniques used to hunt down the most elusive serial offenders.
Making a Murderer
Moira Demos · Series · 2015
Explores: Wrongful Conviction, Police Corruption, Justice System.
If the investigative rigor of American Predator kept you engaged, this series offers a similar, long-form look at the complexities of the justice system and the pursuit of truth.
I'll Be Gone in the Dark
Liz Garbus · Series · 2020
Explores: Citizen Detective, Obsessive Investigation, Cold Case.
This documentary echoes the obsessive, victim-centered investigation found in American Predator, detailing the tireless search for a serial offender who managed to terrorize the public for many years.
To Catch a Predator
Series · 2004
Shares a thread with American Predator: True Crime.
If American Predator hit, To Catch a Predator shares the thread.
Podcasts on the same thread
Park Predators
Podcast
Shares 2 threads with American Predator: Unsolved Mysteries, True Crime.
Just as American Predator investigates the specific hunting grounds of Israel Keyes, this podcast explores the dark, hidden dangers lurking within the vast and isolated spaces of national parks.
Unravelling Amy
Podcast
Shares 2 threads with American Predator: true crime, Criminal Psychology.
If American Predator hit, Unravelling Amy shares the thread.
Keep exploring
Common questions
Is American Predator based on a true story?
Yes, American Predator is a non-fiction book by journalist Maureen Callahan. It documents the true crimes of Israel Keyes, an ambitious serial killer who operated for fourteen years by traveling across the country to abduct and murder strangers before returning to his normal life.
How long was Israel Keyes active according to American Predator?
According to American Predator, Israel Keyes was active for fourteen years. During this period, he utilized a methodical approach involving flying to various cities, renting cars, and driving thousands of miles to commit his crimes before returning home without being detected by law enforcement.
Why did the FBI consider the subject of American Predator unprecedented?
The FBI considered Israel Keyes, the subject of American Predator, unprecedented because of his unique methodology. Unlike many serial killers, Keyes did not target specific locations or victim types, instead choosing to fly to random cities to abduct and kill strangers in broad daylight.
What is the primary focus of the book American Predator?
American Predator focuses on the investigative journey into the crimes of Israel Keyes. The book details how Keyes evaded capture for over a decade by traveling extensively to commit his murders, a pattern of behavior that the FBI found to be highly unusual and ambitious.