What to read, watch, and listen to if you lovedAll Her Fault
Megan Gallagher · Series · 2025
If you loved All Her Fault, start with My Fault: London (2025) — a film on the same thread. Below: 4 books, 4 films and 2 podcasts, each matched to All Her Fault across media.
You were hooked by the way All Her Fault turns a mundane suburban errand into a chilling, high-stakes disappearance mystery.
Books on the same thread
We Are All Guilty Here
Karin Slaughter · Book
Explores: Secrets and lies, Missing persons, Community corruption.
Like All Her Fault, this story exploits the vulnerability of a small community where the sudden disappearance of children shatters the illusion of safety and exposes deep-seated local secrets.
Where are the Children?
Mary Higgins Clark · Book · 1992
Shares a thread with All Her Fault: Domestic Thriller.
If the parental dread in All Her Fault gripped you, this classic captures the same visceral agony of a mother fighting to prove her innocence after a tragic disappearance.
My Husband's Wife
Alice Feeney · Book · 2026
Explores: betrayal, hidden identity, obsession.
This psychological masterpiece mirrors the gaslighting and identity-based tension found in All Her Fault, ensuring you remain as suspicious of the characters as you were during Marissa's frantic search.
All the Missing Girls
Megan Miranda · Book · 2017
Shares a thread with All Her Fault: Psychological Thriller.
This narrative echoes the unsettling uncertainty of All Her Fault by dragging a protagonist back into a past trauma where the mystery of a missing person refuses to stay buried.
Films on the same thread
My Fault: London
Film · 2025
Explores: Forbidden Love, Family Secrets, Troubled Past.
If All Her Fault hit, My Fault: London shares the thread.
The Housemaid
Paul Feig · Film · 2025
Shares 2 threads with All Her Fault: Domestic Thriller, Psychological Thriller.
Much like the domestic instability that defines All Her Fault, this story forces you into a dangerous household where the people you trust are masking their true, sinister intentions.
Weapons
Zach Cregger · Film · 2025
Explores: Child Disappearance, Small Town Secrets, Community Trauma.
This film captures the same gut-wrenching premise as All Her Fault, focusing on the collective trauma and community-wide panic that erupts when children vanish without a trace.
The Woman in Cabin 10
Simon Stone · Film · 2025
Shares 2 threads with All Her Fault: Mistaken Identity, Psychological Thriller.
The gaslighting and isolation of the protagonist in this mystery mirror the experience in All Her Fault, where your perspective is constantly challenged by others denying the reality you witnessed.
Podcasts on the same thread
CounterClock
Audiochuck · Podcast · 2025
Explores: unsolved homicide, seeking justice, historical mystery.
If All Her Fault hit, CounterClock shares the thread.
The Deck Investigates
Audiochuck · Podcast
Explores: Missing Persons, Unsolved Mysteries, Small Town Secrets.
This investigative journey mirrors the parental desperation in All Her Fault, focusing on a mother whose sudden disappearance remains a haunting, unsolved mystery that reveals painful domestic secrets.
Keep exploring
Common questions
Is All Her Fault a television series?
Yes, All Her Fault is a television production released in 2025. It is based on the story of Marissa Irvine arriving at 14 Arthur Avenue to find her son Milo missing after a playdate, triggering a search for his whereabouts.
What is the primary setting for All Her Fault?
The events of All Her Fault take place in Chicago. The central mystery begins when Marissa Irvine arrives at 14 Arthur Avenue for her son's playdate and discovers that the woman who answers the door does not have Milo.
Who is the central character in All Her Fault?
The central character in All Her Fault is Marissa Irvine. She is a mother who experiences a nightmare scenario when she arrives to pick up her son, Milo, from a playdate only to find that he is not at the location.
How does All Her Fault begin?
All Her Fault begins when Marissa Irvine arrives at 14 Arthur Avenue to pick up her son, Milo, from his first playdate. The story unfolds when the woman who answers the door is not the mother she expected and does not have Milo.