If you loved
All Good Things
Film · 2010
If All Good Things captivated you, you will appreciate these stories that expose how obsession and hidden secrets dismantle lives.
Books on the same thread
A Good Girl's Guide to Murder
Holly Jackson · Book · 2021
Much like the investigation in All Good Things, this story centers on a cold case where the drive to uncover buried truths transforms into an all-consuming personal obsession.
Killers of the Flower Moon: The Osage Murders and the Birth of the FBI
David Grann · Book · 2018
This account of systemic corruption mirrors the dark exploration of wealth and power found in All Good Things, highlighting how monstrous crimes thrive within the shadows of influence.
Critical
Robin Cook · Book · 2007
Fans of the medical and investigative elements in All Good Things will find a similar tension here, as the protagonists navigate institutional corruption to solve a dangerous mystery.
The Heaven & Earth Grocery Store
James McBride · Book · 2023
This novel echoes the way All Good Things uses a long-buried discovery to peel back layers of community secrets, showing how historical injustices continue to haunt the present day.
Series on the same thread
A Good Girl's Guide to Murder
Series · 2024
If you were drawn to the relentless pursuit of answers in All Good Things, you will recognize that same investigative spirit as Pippa challenges an established, tragic narrative.
Honeymoon Se Hatya
Mrunalini Havaldar · Series · 2026
This docudrama explores the same dark marital fractures and betrayal that fueled the tragedy of All Good Things, focusing on the fatal breakdown of trust between intimate partners.
True Detective
Nic Pizzolatto · Series · 2014
Like All Good Things, this series uses a layered investigation to unearth the deep psychological trauma and personal secrets that define the lives of those caught in a mystery.
Forever
Matthew Miller · Series · 2014
The protagonist in this series shares the analytical focus of the leads in All Good Things, using his unique position to peel back the layers of long-held secrets.
Podcasts on the same thread
CounterClock
Audiochuck · Podcast · 2025
This podcast mirrors the investigative rigor of All Good Things, as it revisits cold cases to reignite public interest and seek justice for events lost to the past.
Crime Junkie
Audiochuck · Podcast · 2026
The narrative style here feeds the same hunger for truth that All Good Things evokes, proving that an obsession with the details of a crime is universal.
Keep exploring
Common questions
Is All Good Things based on a true story?
Yes, All Good Things is based on the true love story and murder mystery of the most notorious unsolved murder case in New York history. The film utilizes newly-discovered facts, court records, and speculation to elaborate on the events surrounding the case.
What is the focus of All Good Things?
All Good Things focuses on the complex relationship and subsequent murder investigation that became the most notorious unsolved case in New York history. The film reconstructs the narrative using historical records and evidence to explore the mystery behind the events.
Does All Good Things solve the murder case it depicts?
All Good Things depicts the most notorious unsolved murder case in New York history. The film uses court records and speculation to elaborate on the story, but it does not provide a definitive resolution to the case, which remains unsolved in reality.
How does All Good Things incorporate real-world evidence?
All Good Things incorporates real-world evidence by drawing upon newly-discovered facts and official court records. These materials are used to elaborate on the true love story and the specific circumstances of the murder mystery that serves as the basis for the film.